Nik said:
If anything you'd think a Toronto bias would help Alfredsson as it's really only within the context of the Leafs-Sens rivalry that Alfredsson was a particularly important player.
Other than that Alfredsson's career is really the story of a guy who was frequently only the 2nd or 3rd best forward on his own team.
Yeah. His career numbers are good but not HHOF good, and without much serious consideration for any major end of season awards, his case is just not great. Hall of Very Good, but not Hall of Fame.