GhostofPotvin29
New member
Chev-boyar-sky said:L K said:Phaneuf is not an offensive defenseman at all anymore.
Weird eh?
You'd never guess from his shots and lack of offensive poise with the puck that he could've posted 20, 17 and 17 goals in consecutive season.
You think he ever practices his shot anymore? He should.
I've been over this before, but he posted those totals in a) seasons after first lockout with elevated PP's around the league and b) with averaging around 5:00 on the PP per game.
With the Leafs, while he still gets #1 unit PP time, the PP is hardly ever set up to filter through a one-timer by him so he hardly gets the opportunities anymore that he had in Calgary. As a result his shots are way down. 2010-11 was really the last time he shot the puck at a similar rate to when he was in Calgary. He had 39 PP goals in his first 3 seaons, he just does not get those opportunities anymore.
His offensive production was fine really right up to the end of the lockout shortened season. I don't think it's fair to say he's "not an offensive defenseman at all anymore" though, his offense will never repeat those seasons in Calgary because the factors for that production don't exist anymore. He still puts up points but he's asked to do so in a much more physically taxing environment than he had to do so in Calgary, and with probably half the offensive opportunities that he was afforded there.