Peter D. said:
When I saw this come across the ticker the other day I was completely shocked. Never thought Lou would ever leave New Jersey and was completely taken aback that the Leafs were able to get such a high profile name for the position. It was thought it'd almost be a puppet coming in with the layers of management already insulating/surrounding the position.
This is a great hire. They basically insinuated this is a move to groom Dubas for the position. He's a living legend so there aren't many better people to learn from. The Hockey News had a great article on Lou a couple issues ago, and it showed how professional, hands on and aware he was of the entire organization from top to bottom. If he can teach and help instil a similar structure for the Leafs organization, that alone would make his hire a huge success.
I have a similar reaction to this. Super surprised, and largely positive. The professionalism piece, and the loyalty and respect he fostered even with players he traded and people he fired is a rare gift.
There are some (well-founded) concerns regarding the last decade or so of Lou's tenure with the Devils that was fraught with stagnant performance, poor drafting (in options and choices), and that Kovalchuk thing (A: that contract B: how he left).
I think this could really work if Lamoriello focused on the infrastructure of the rebuilding Leaf brand (professionalism/'culture'), and merely advised on the on-ice product moves by greasing the wheels of negotiation with his relationships, ostensibly to groom Dubas/Hunter for full-GM duties (my bet is on Dubas taking over in 3 years).