CarltonTheBear said:
Yup, but I think the worst thing Burke could do is go with Reimer and Scrivens next season. That just screams disaster. Go with one or the other and a veteran guy. My preference would be to keep Scrivens.
That's what I was implying. 20 games of solid goaltending from Reimer was great and everything, but he wasn't good in the preseason. He wasn't all that good in the first 3 games of the year before Gomez took his head off either. And then he was awful the rest of the year aside from a week long stretch of games.
I think you need to bring someone in to be the #1 guy next year and then let Reimer and Scrivens fight it out for the backup/1B role. If they both suck, you pick the least awful one, try and send the other guy to the minors and if you lose you, so be it, else, consider a trade.